Feds Cape Cod island cottages endangered must go

Post on: 2011-09-05 By: admin

CHATHAM, Mass. (AP) — On a speck of island across Chatham Harbor, a weathered doorway opens to a cottage where beach towels substitute for couch covers and an old-fashioned hand pump counts as a kitchen faucet — with no option for "hot."This Cape Cod dune cottage, known as the "Carroll Camp," has no electricity. The only running water flows off the roof into barrels that feed a shower and the sink. At night, the brightest lights flicker from a nearby lighthouse.But families stay on the island for weeks at a time, spread out among wood-sided and cedar-shingle cottages built between beaches and bayberry bushes. A boat ride is the only way in. The trip covers less than a mile, but feels farther when visitors step into the chilly shallows and head to shore."It's like coming to heaven," said Susan Carroll, whose family has leased the tiny, gray cottage for 20 yearsBut no place is perfect. The ocean that gives the cottage its remoteness is also washing away the 250-acre island.Last month, the Cape Cod National Seashore told the Carrolls that, for public safety, their annual lease was being terminated and the camp was going to be burned or demolished. Now, the Carrolls and four other families with similar cottages on North Beach Island have until next month to get personal items out.The decision has brought sadness and outrage in Chatham, where the rustic camps are fixtures on the horizon. Residents say demolishing five of the existing 11 camps is unnecessary, and a pointless hit to the town's heritage."I have never seen a more sort of callous and unilateral decision by a government entity in my time on the board," said town selectman Sean Summers. "Those camps are part of our collective soul, really, as a community."George Price, head of the agency, a National Park Service division which owns the camps, said he realizes the camps are special to Chatham and families whose children "virtually grew up there."But the shoreline, on the ocean side, is retreating back about 80 feet per year, he added. Two of the camps likely won't make it through the winter and need to be quickly removed before they collapse. And the others have no more than a season or two left. Tropical storm Irene had virtually no effect on the camps but the concern is the next storms inevitably will.It's far cheaper to remove all the camps at one time, Price said."In this particular case, Mother Nature has worked against us," Price said. "We believe the window of opportunity is fairly limited before the majority of the winter storms actually come in."Chatham's Coastal Resources Director, Ted Keon, agrees with the Seashore's decision, which he says was sudden but not surprising. The erosion is intensifying, the risk of the collapse of the camps is real, he said, and so are the hazards the debris could in create in the waterways."(If it's) obvious that things need to get removed, you should remove it ahead of time as opposed to just sitting back and letting it get knocked down," Keon said.The existing camps first popped up on the beach in the 1940s, after locals paid a few hundred dollars for a plot of land and built the camps as retreats or as hunting and fishing cottages.The government took over some of the camps after the Cape Cod National Seashore was established in 1961 to preserve the coastline.Anyone whose camp was built after 1959, or who couldn't prove ownership, lost their camp, but received compensation or usage rights in return. The other camps remain privately-owned.Today, the Seashore leases each of the five camps it owns for $8,000 a year. The Carrolls, for instance, pay for it by renting out their year-round home on mainland Chatham during the summer weeks they stay at the camp.The island's recent natural history is dynamic and at times devastating for the camps. It was once part of a continuous barrier beach, but became part of a peninsula in 1987 when the sea broke through south of the camps. Four years later, the so-called "Perfect Storm" of October 1991 wiped the camps out, though many were later rebuilt on sturdy pilings to brace against another catastrophic hit.Remnants of roads are remindersthat the land was recently accessible from the mainland, until the ocean split through north of the camps during an April 2007 nor'easter.The island is now about 2.5 miles long, two-tenths of a mile wide at its widest point, and high tide creeps to within yards of a couple camps.No one disputes the island is breaking down, but people want to preserve the camps as long as possible, said Susan's husband, Roger Carroll. He said his camp and others are in no imminent danger, and will sit rock-steady for some time on the deep pilings they were built upon following the 1991 storm. The Seashore made a rash decision for reasons it still hasn't justified, he said."They kind of left us alone for all these years, and then all of the sudden they're in a panic to get them all out," he said. "It's like you lost a member of the family."The small community of camp residents has grown close over the years. But Summers, who doesn't have a camp on the island, said even Chatham residents who don't use the camps value them, seeing them as key reminders of the "fishing and fowling existence" that's the region's true heritage.Some residents are now pushing to have the camps listed on the National Register of Historic Places, as a way to force the Seashore to consider ways to preserve them.Summers added that the Seashore acted before consulting with the town about ways to trim the demolition costs or lessen the potential hazards posed by the camps, which Summers believes are wildly overstated.Price acknowledged, "I could have engaged in a public conversation earlier. That's my error."Price said he's still listening as town officials and residents suggest alternatives , but he stood by the projections about the imminent danger to the cottages."The steady degradation of the shoreline is fact," he said.Not all island residents are digging in. Arthur Bloomer's family acquired rights to stay at a North Beach camp in the late 1970s, figuring they had 20 years ahead. Three decades later, the 79-year-old is grateful for the extra time, and "philosophical" about the government's decision.But he added that when the camps are gone, something unique will be lost."There's a way of life over there that nobody understands," he said.
@yahoonews on Twitter, become a fan on Facebook
Top Stories »Dismal jobs data shakes Asian marketsLibya rebels: talks for loyalist town have failedA weakened Lee still poses flood threat in SouthWind-driven fires kill woman, child in East TexasGadhafi leaned on Arab allies to stay in powerTough economic climate as Obama seeks 2nd termSmall plane crash sparks rapid brush fire in Calif
Most PopularTea party bulling its way into 2012 GOP raceCheney: US different if Hillary Clinton presidentWhat could Obama have done differently to create jobs and improve the economy?Unexpected legacy left by hero of Flight 93Perry's fiery 'Fed Up!' may come back to haunt himTough economic climate as Obama seeks 2nd term
Today on Yahoo!1 - 4 of 36prevnext
Scary moment for Nadal at the U.S. Open
Uproar over bizarre photo shoot
Why men don't call for a second date
Justin Bieber schools NBA star in hoops
Sign into post a comment, orSign upfor a free account.
Popular NowNewestOldestMost Replied
Oh no. Some rich New Englanders have to lose their summer cottage. I feel so bad for them while my household can barely pay the bills every month because I can't find a job. Wah. I'm crying for them. Really. *retch*
News For YouNewborn fatally mauled by family dog near HoustonJordan woman killed in hospital over pregnancyUtah ends 4-day workweek experimentFormer German leader calls for "United States of Europe"HIV-positive porn performer retests negativeIndia paid $5 bn Iran oil debt in full: central bankOfficer who had sex on car fired by NM policeSarah Palin 'Big Announcement' Flakes OutFreed nurse describes 'living hell''30 Rock' Actor Cheyenne Jackson Marries Longtime Partner
US News »Storm Lee threatens Southeast with heavy rains NEW ORLEANS (Reuters) - After testing New Orleans' flood defenses over the weekend, Tropical Storm Lee moved northeast on Monday after weakening to a tropical depression, and threatened to bring heavy rains and flooding to a large section of the U.S. Southeast.Obama vows federal help for Irene victims PATERSON, New Jersey (Reuters) - President Barack Obama on Sunday urged Republicans not to play politics with federal disaster aid as he toured flood-stricken New Jersey and pledged to do everything possible to help states recover after Hurricane Irene.No apology from N.Y. Mayor Bloomberg over aide's arrest NEW YORK (Reuters) - New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg declined to apologize on Sunday for how he handled the resignation of a former deputy mayor, who was arrested on a domestic violence charge.Tropical Storm Lee spawns tornadoes on Gulf Coast MOBILE, Ala (Reuters) - Tropical Storm Lee spawned tornado sightings and alerts from the Louisiana Gulf Coast to the Florida panhandle on Sunday, and at least two deaths related to the storm were reported.Australia's Howard a surprise 9-11 witness SYDNEY (Reuters) - Australia's former Prime Minister John Howard, a surprise witness to the September11, 2001, attacks on the United States, believes former U.S. President George W. Bush deserves more praise for his response and for stopping further attacks.
FeaturedShoe repairman's successA shop owner battles back after 9/11 destroys his business, leaving him $400,000 in debt. More»Shoe repairman's successUpgrade Your Life5 ways to make an easy-to-remember, ultra-secure password. More»Upgrade Your LifeKey votersWill a growing Latino population tip the scales in 2012? More»Key votersVideo: Who Knew?Why festival is called Burning Man. More»Video: Who Knew?
EducationSix quick-start careersWith the right preparation, you could be prepared for a new career in 1-2 years.What's the hottest field right now?See how you could prepare for a career in this hot industry.
Yahoo! NewsHomeU.S.WorldBusinessEntertainmentSportsTechPoliticsScienceHealthBlogsSept. 11PopularAll Yahoo! News »
Also On Yahoo!AutosFinanceGamesGroupsHealthMapsMoviesMusicomg!ShineShoppingSportsTravelTVAll Yahoo! »
Trending NowRegis PhilbinMadonnaAl PacinoBeyonceBurning ManHugh LaurieLabor DayCollege studentsCam NewtonGas prices
Copyright 2011 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Copyright © 2011 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved.

Article original from: http://news.yahoo.com/feds-cape-cod-island-cottages-endangered-must-162925791.html